For and against method imre lakatos and paul feyerabend. The only principle that does not inhibit progress is. Feyerabends criticism against the fetishes of rationalism. Hacking reflects on both feyerabends life and personality as well as the broader significance of the book for current discussions.
Was philosopher paul feyerabend really sciences worst enemy. Paul karl feyerabend january, 1924 february 11, 1994 was an austrianborn philosopher of science best known for his work as a profe. New left books, 1975, which he sometimes conceived of as a letter to lakatos to whom the book is dedicated. Introduction to the fourth edition by ian haddng against method is more than a book. Modern philosophy of science has paid great attention to the understanding of scientific practice, in contrast to concentration on scientific method.
He opposed a single, tradition, scientific method, arguing that any such method of putting some limits on the activities of scientists, and thus limits of the progress. Paul feyerabends globally acclaimed work, which sparked and continues to stimulate fierce debate, examines the deficiencies of many widespread ideas about scientific progress and the nature of knowledge. Feyerabend argues that scientific advances can only be understood in a historical context. This book was, he emphasised, a collage of earlier papers, spiced up with challenging rhetoric. His books include philosophical papers, farewell to reason, and against method. This book does precisely what it says it will do challenge the scientific methods claim as the epistemology. Outline of an anarchistic theory of knowledge is a 1975 book about the philosophy of science by paul feyerabend, in which the author argues.
What remains in against method reads as exactly that. Feyerabend was already a wellknown philosopher of science by the time it first appeared in essay form 1970. The turbulent sixties were winding down, and here was an intellectual testament to the ferment. Paul feyerabend wrote science in a free society shortly after against method 1975 in response to critics of the book. Since it was first published in 1975, against method has followed poppers the logic. Paul feyerabend lived at various times in austria, the uk, the united states, new zealand, italy, germany, and finally in switzerland. This book expanded on the belief that science was not supposed to be used in a specific fashion, bacons scientific method, but to be open to all potential possibilities of finding results. Feyerabend makes a detailed demolition of the so called received view of philosophy of science i. Paul feyerabends argument for anything goes in science. Beyond popper and kuhn to an anarchist philosophy of science. Paul feyerabends globally acclaimed work, which sparked and continues to stimulate fierce. We suggest that one can read the 1975 edition of against method as a transitional work. Feyerabend denies method supremacy over contextual and meaning rich subjective thinking, and marshals the facts of history to establish the lack of any single method or welldefined body such as science in the growth of human knowledge.
Feyerabend is argumentative to the point of being petulant, attacking specific critics on minor points, restating and resettling purely professional arguments. Buy against method book online at low prices in india. The new edition merges parts of against method with ex cerpts from. There have been dramatic political, social and ecological changes. In his book against method and science in a free society, feyerabend defended the idea that there is no methodological rules, which are always used by scientists. In the context of this work, the term anarchy refers to epistemological anarchy. Against method by feyerabend, paul find or buy book now. But when i got to feyerabends against method 1975 i was tempted, to quote david hume, to consign it to the flames, since it appeared to me to contain nothing but sophistry and illusion. Tomas petricek on paul feyerabends the against method.
His major works include against method published in 1975, science in a free society published in 1978 and farewell to reason a collection of papers published in 1987. Analytical index being a sketch of the main argument and the concluding chapter from against method 1975 publ. Naturalized philosophy of science with a plurality of methods. A more accurate description, however, is the one given in. In 1975 paul feyerabend published his first book, which was titled, against method. Paul feyerabend was professor of philosophy at uc berkeley, and professor of the philosophy of science at the federal institute of technology at zurich. Against method paul feyerabend, paul k autor feyerabend.
His first and most famous book, against method, argued that philosophy cannot provide a rationale for science, since there is. Ian hacking is emeritus professor of philosophy at the university of toronto. If rules or a model had been followed, the discovery would not have been made. Published november 17th 1993 by verso first published 1975.
Including lakatoss lectures on scientific method and the lakatosfeyerabend correspondence, imre lakatos and paul feyerabend is published by university of chicago press. Feyerabend became famous for his purportedly anarchistic view of science and his rejection of the existence of universal methodological rules. Feyerabend has been a prolific and influential writer in the philosophy of science for the last two decades, but, unlike popper, kuhn, toulmin, and most other leading philosophers of science, his writings have appeared mainly in journals or specialized collections. That was what it felt like, when the work came out in 1975. Just the analytical table of contents and concluding chapter reproduced here. Analysis of feyerabends against method philosophy essay. Then the years passed, and with age and experience my thinking about the nature of science got a bit wiser. Against method feyerabend publishes his book against method. What are the reasons for employing such an odd conjunction of premises.
Paul feyerabend stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. In his book, feyerabend argues that science has no set model. So starts his book against method and through detailed analysis of the scientists and the phenomenon in question feyerabend proceeds to demolish any assertions which compress science into a box which stands alone outside of all other influences such as religion, history, culture or philosophy. Feyerabends previous popular work, against method 1975, established him as an outspoken, controversial critic of the scientific and philosophical establishments. Paul feyerabends acclaimed work, which has contributed greatly to this new emphasis, shows the deficiencies of some widespread ideas about the nature of knowledge. Books ordered may be returned for a full refund if they are not as described. Feyerabend intended this book as the initial salvo in what he and fellow philosopher of science imre lakatos had hoped to be an ongoing exchange, until the latters untimely death ended that possibility. Many things have happened since i first published against method am for short. Buy against method by paul feyerabend online at alibris. Freedom has increased but it has brought hunger, insecurity, nationalistic tensions, wars and straightforward murder. He argues that if we look at discoveries throughout history, specifically at the works of galileo no model or rules were followed. Since it was first published in 1975, against method has followed poppers the logic of scientific discovery and kuhns the structure of scientific revolutions into becoming a classic text in the debate about scientific methodology and scientific reasoning. World leaders have met to deal with the deterioration of our.
Outline of an anarchistic theory of knowledge, remains among the more contentious and influential philosophical works of the past decades. The idea of a method that contains firm, unchanging, and absolutely binding principles for conducting the business of science meets considerable difficulty when confronted with the results of historical research. Appearance of feyerabends first book, against method, setting out epistemological anarchism, whose main thesis was that there is no such thing as the scientific method. Paul feyerabends against method marxists internet archive.
Feyerabend was notorious, adored by the young, loathed by the established. New left books 1975 abstract feyerabrend argues that intellectual progress relies on the creativity of the scientist, against the authority of science. His major works include against method published in 1975, science in a free society published in 1978 and farewell to reason published in 1987. In science in a free society, feyerabend claims that science is essentially ruled under government law and is not permitted the right of free expression. The body of the work is a detailed historical case study which he uses to make a historicist argument against the current scientific method. The method that he is against is the scientific method, or rather, the enthronement of the scientific method as dogma. Outline of an anarchistic theory of knowledge is a 1975 book about the philosophy of science by paul feyerabend, in which the author argues that science is an anarchic enterprise, not a nomic customary one. In his book against method 1975 he uses historical case studies i. Ill be mostly talking about paul feyerabends against method, but as a computer scientist myself, ill insert a number of examples based on my experience with theoretical programming. New scientist since it was first published in 1975, against method has followed poppers the logic of scientific discovery and kuhns the structure of scientific revolutions into becoming a classic text in the debate about scientific methodology and scientific reasoning.
Was philosopher paul feyerabend really sciences worst. Great scientists are methodological opportunists who use any moves that come to hand, even if they thereby violate canons of empiricist methodology. Paul karl feyerabend philosopher of science and educator. Outline of an anarchistic theory of knowledge article pdf available in philosophia 61. Book search engine can find against method by feyerabend, paul.
Feyerabend likes to play provocateur, he likes to make big, brash, surprising statements, but his arguments are more subtle than they seem. Logical empiricism and popper and its attempts to discover rules of scientific method. He is the author of historical ontology, scientific revolutions, and. This complaint has been made numerous times by feyerabends commentators agassi, 1976. In 1975, berkeley philosopher paul feyerabend wrote a book called against method, in which he saidone of the most striking features of recent discussions in the history and philosophy of science is the realization that events and developments.
1490 1478 427 1201 483 398 874 156 1626 848 319 392 1440 954 110 580 1495 300 1473 214 931 784 1072 1462 879 591 1367 618 23 311 648